State governments control voter lists for parliamentary and assembly elections?

checkthis · automated fact-check · How we check

False

Checked 14 Oct 2026 · Updated 15 Oct 2026

The Reel's central argument rests on a false premise. Under Indian law, the preparation and maintenance of electoral rolls for Assembly and Parliamentary elections are the constitutional responsibility of the Election Commission of India (ECI), an independent central body, not state governments. Additionally, local civic authorities clarified that Prakash Raj's name was not actually deleted from the voter list.

Main source: Election Commission

What it claims isn't true. Reel by @itisatp

▶

The Reel we checked

@itisatp

fraaaaands #prakashraj #narendramodi #voterslist #indianpolitics

Watch the Reel on Instagram ↗

🚩 What's concerning

Lapse

The Election Commission of India forced officers in Uttar Pradesh to sign voter deletion forms without providing reasons after the legally mandated deadline.

"The Election Commission of India (ECI) forced officers in Uttar Pradesh to sign deletion forms for 85,854 voters without giving any reason during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in the state. All these deletion forms were submitted…" The Reporters' Collective, 2026-10-09

Election Commission of India response: "We sent detailed questions to UP Chief Electoral Officer Navdeep Rinwa as well as to the ECI in Delhi. They had not replied by the time of publication." The Reporters' Collective

What we checked

State governments, not Prime Minister Narendra Modi, are responsible for ensuring eligible voters are properly included in the voter list.Election Commission

The speaker's name was removed from the voter list during the SIR process.No reliable source found for this yet.

What the other side said

Points the Reel argues against or mocks, checked too.

Prakash Raj was one of 6.5 million voters whose names were deleted from the voter list following the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).Not confirmed

What each side says

BJP Karnataka / CorporationAuthorities state that official verification showed Raj had shifted from his registered address rather than facing arbitrary deletion. Times of India

How it plays you

It wants you to think: "Critics of the central government are ignorant complainers who do not understand basic administrative responsibilities."

Insulting a critic's personal life does not disprove administrative facts, and the Reel's primary premise—that state governments manage voter lists—is legally false.

Ad hominem attack: "My dear cringe brother, Prakash Raj. I have a simple advice for you because it seems that you are frustrated with your…". It attacks the critic's personal life and career to undermine his credibility and deflect from administrative questions about voter list revisions.
False administrative premise: "you should question the state government because they are responsible for ensuring eligible voters are properly…". It confidently assigns election roll duties to state governments to dismiss complaints against central authorities, even though constitutional authority rests with the Election Commission of India.
Loaded language and mockery: "when you guys do it, it is like some buffalo coming and screaming in English". It uses derogatory similes to mock the critic's language and delivery, distracting the audience from the factual core of the issue.

Short version

❌ FALSE 👉 The Reel's central argument rests on a false premise. 👉 Under Indian law, the preparation and maintenance of electoral rolls for Assembly and Parliamentary elections are the constitutional responsibility of the Election Commission of India (ECI), an independent central body, not state governments. 👉 Additionally, local civic authorities clarified that Prakash Raj's name was not actually deleted from the voter list. 📰 Source: Election Commission 🔎 Full check: send this Reel to @checkthis.chat

Does this look wrong?

Related checks

MisleadingIndia is uniquely stable while European nations suffer widespread instabilityPolitics · Trick: Picks only some facts · 19 Oct 2026

No proof yetMahua Moitra was singled out regarding Circuit House accommodation@advcsankit · Politics · 18 Oct 2026

Half the storyBBC headlines prove biased reporting on student protests worldwidePolitics · Trick: Mixes up two things · 18 Oct 2026

Check a Reel yourself

Send any Reel to @checkthis.chat on Instagram. You get a reply like this in a minute or two.

Send a Reel