checkthis / Fact checks / Money
The Reel says
Government routinely rewards negligent and accused public officials with promotions?
The post accurately highlights that 22 people died and hundreds were hospitalized during the Indore contaminated water crisis, and IAS officer Rohit Sissodiya was later appointed District Collector shortly after an inquiry report. However, it omits vital context regarding newly appointed Sikkim Governor Dushyant Gautam.
- 6 claims checked
- 6 sources
- Checked 25 Oct 2026
- Main source: Indore tragedy: Judicial probe points to a chain of civic failures behind contaminated-water deaths
▶The Reel we checked
@replay.voice
The Indore contaminated water crisis has raised serious questions about administrative accountability and public safety. According to the inquiry report…
Watch on Instagram ↗⚖️ Where the case stands
🗣️ Alleged
- Ankita Bhandari's parents: “Bhandari's parents have alleged BJP leader Gautam's involvement in the case.” New Indian Express, 2026-10-14
- Their response: “he has never been named as an accused, charge-sheeted, or implicated by any investigating agency in the case.” All India Radio, 2026-01-07
- Their response: a defamation case: “The court found the posts linking BJP leader Dushyant Gautam to the Ankita Bhandari murder case to be "prima facie defamatory" and baseless.” Bigstorynetwork, 2026-01-07
❓ Still open
- No court has ruled on the allegations above in any source we found.
The trick: Picks only some facts
It shows the facts that fit and leaves out those that don't (known as cherry-picking).
“और अभी अंकिता भंडारी वाले case में तो हद ही कर दी गई है। वो VIP जिस पर आरोप लगे उसे सीधा governor ही बना दिया गया। अब उस पर कई सालों तक कार्रवाई तो दूर की बात है, case भी दर्ज नहीं हो सकता है।”
How this trick works and how to answer it →
What we checked
Connected
- The same claim was checked in another Reel (@dhruvrathee, 2026-10-20): “BJP leader Dushyant Gautam, who was accused in the Ankita Bhandari murder case, was appointed Governor of…”, found not confirmed (see it)
- The same claim was checked in another Reel (@unknown, ): “The prime suspect in the Ankita Bhandari murder case is the Governor of Sikkim.”, found not confirmed (see it)
What the Reel doesn't tell you
- Dushyant Gautam has denied the allegations against him in the Ankita Bhandari case.
How it plays you
It wants you to think: “The government systematically protects and rewards guilty officials and politicians to shield them from punishment.”
While certain administrative appointments of criticized officials did occur, presenting someone never charged by investigators and cleared by courts as a guilty VIP creates a flawed premise of deliberate institutional protection.
- Generalisation from individual cases: “पूरे देश में यह trend बन गया है”. It stitches together separate incidents across different states and administrative cadres to assert a nationwide deliberate policy of rewarding wrongdoers.
- Loaded language: “मल मूत्र से मिला हुआ पानी पिलाया”. It employs graphic imagery to elicit visceral disgust and shock, priming the audience to absorb sweeping conclusions about government intent.
Short version
Does this look wrong?
Related checks
Alex Karp said successful leaders hide their intelligence@entrepreneursonig · Money · 24 Oct 2026
A man bought a Porsche after an elderly woman was excluded@wealth · Money · 24 Oct 2026
India's 7.8% GDP growth is calculated correctly, not 2.6%@shivin.chaudhary · Money · 23 Oct 2026
Check a Reel yourself
Send any Reel to @checkthis.chat on Instagram. You get a reply like this in a minute or two.
Send a Reel