No proof yetTrick: Name-drops authority

The 86% fiscal contribution figure comes from the creator's own report, not an independent source. While some employment challenges are documented, researchers debate the overall economic impact of immigration.

Nobody reliable has confirmed this. Reel by @observatoireid · checked 9 Oct 2026 · Politics

The Reel we checked

@observatoireid

🔴🇫🇷 Trois idées reçues sur l'immigration : - Les immigrés rapportent plus qu'ils ne coûtent aux finances publiques ? Selon l'OCDE pour l’année 2017, les…

Watch the Reel on Instagram ↗

The trick: Name-drops authority

It uses someone's status instead of evidence (known as appeal to authority).

"Selon l'OCDE, les immigrés ne couvrent par leurs contributions que 86 %"

Citing selective institutional statistics does not fully capture complex socio-economic debates involving multiple variables.

How this trick works and how to answer it →

What we checked

According to the OECD, immigrants in France only cover 86% of the public expenditures allocated to them through their contributions.Only source found: the creator's own publication. Nobody independent confirms it yet.

Only 14 percent of residence permits issued in France last year were for economic reasons.No reliable source found for this yet.

Only 56 percent of non-European foreigners of working age in France hold a job.No reliable source found for this yet.

Two out of three foreign students in France do not complete their undergraduate degree in three years.No reliable source found for this yet.

What the Reel doesn't tell you

More than one in five jobs in France, or 5.4 million jobs, remain inaccessible to non-EU foreigners, according to the Observatory on Inequalities.

How it tries to persuade you

It wants you to think: "Immigrants are a drain on France's public finances and economy."

A single fiscal ratio does not capture the full picture. Economists point out that immigrants contribute to wealth creation in other ways, such as entrepreneurship and consumption, which are not reflected in direct tax-to-expenditure ratios.

Selective framing: "seuls 56 % des étrangers extra-européens occupent un emploi". The creator highlights low employment rates among non-EU foreigners.

Does this look wrong?

Check a Reel yourself

Send any Reel to @checkthis.chat on Instagram. You get a reply like this in a minute or two.

Send a Reel